20-minute diagnostic
EN
Perspectives / Founders & operators

A senior executive has resigned. Listen before making a counteroffer.

A chief executive listens as a senior colleague explains his decision to resign

When a senior executive resigns, the first response is often practical: Can we match the offer? Who will cover the role? What will the board think? Those questions matter. They are not the first questions to answer.

Start by understanding why the person is leaving.

Hear the decision before you negotiate

Ask whether the decision is final. If it is, acknowledge that and discuss a professional transition. If the person is open to a conversation, ask what led them to this point and what has changed in the role.

Questions that can help:

  • What made you decide to leave now?
  • What has become harder or less workable in the role?
  • Is there something you raised earlier that did not get resolved?
  • If a specific condition changed, would you want to stay, or have you already decided to move on?

Then listen without preparing a rebuttal. The person may be leaving over pay. They may have lost authority, become responsible for outcomes without control over the decisions, or stopped trusting the working relationship. They may want a different challenge or simply be ready for a change. Those are different situations and call for different responses.

Do not let the counteroffer define the problem

A pay increase is an appropriate answer to a compensation issue. It does not resolve a role that has become too narrow, repeated interference in the executive’s decisions, or a relationship that has broken down. If those conditions stay in place, a larger number may postpone the same decision.

Company leaders review how to cover key responsibilities after an executive's departure

Before proposing terms, summarize what you heard and ask whether you have understood it. Be clear about which changes the company can make, who has authority to approve them, and when they could take effect. If the requested change cannot be delivered, say so plainly. A promise made to keep someone through the week can become a second reason to leave later.

The decision is not only whether the person might accept an offer. Consider whether keeping them is right for both sides. Would the new arrangement be sustainable? Can the company honor it without creating commitments it cannot support? Is the executive genuinely willing to stay, or trying to leave on better financial terms? Give them room to answer honestly.

If they stay, make the change concrete

Write down the agreed role, decision rights, reporting line, compensation and any other changes. Include when each change begins and when you will review how it is working. Tell the relevant people enough to make the new arrangement real; a private agreement that leaves the team following the old chain of command will not fix the problem.

Do not frame staying as proof of loyalty. The company and executive are making a working agreement. Both should be able to judge it by whether the agreed conditions hold in practice.

If they leave, manage the work and the relationship

List the decisions, client relationships and recurring responsibilities that depend on the departing executive. Name an interim owner for each, identify decisions that need escalation, and plan how to transfer essential information. Keep the transition focused and professional. Respect the person’s notice obligations and do not rely on unplanned, extended work after their departure.

A resignation can expose a management issue the company has been carrying for some time. It can also be a personal decision that no counteroffer should change. A measured response gives you a better chance of seeing which situation you are dealing with.

In SEAM, I work with founders and executives on a current leadership problem, including the practical conditions around it and the recurring responses that may be keeping it in place. A free twenty-minute diagnostic focuses on one issue and ends with an initial perspective and a practical next step.

Request a free diagnostic